Amy Kline is a commercial litigator whose practice is focused on the representation of insurers and reinsurers in complex civil litigation. She is co-chair of the firm's Insurance Group and a member of the Executive Committee. Amy has extensive trial and appellate experience in federal and state courts, as well as before private arbitration panels.
In addition to her legal practice, Amy is an adjunct professor of law at Villanova University School of Law, where she teaches courses on civil pretrial and judicial externships.
Amy is an avid runner, mountain biker and triathlete. She coaches a mountain bike team, has competed in numerous marathons, half marathons and multi-sport endurance events, and is a two-time Ironman finisher.
Amy has been named a 'Local Litigation Star' in Pennsylvania by Benchmark Litigation since 2022.
Insurance and Reinsurance
- Lead outside counsel to a property and casualty insurer on litigation and coverage matters.
- Representation of life insurers in multiple lawsuits arising from the lapse of variable life and annuity insurance products and the alleged wrongful denial of life and accidental death benefits.
- Representation of a life and long term care insurer in administrative appeals relating to long term care rate increase requests.
- Representation of a national managed care organization in Medicaid-related payor-provider disputes across the country.
- Representation of a group disability insurer defending disability, AD&D and life cases within the Third Circuit.
- Representation of a managed care organization in multiple challenges to the award of a state Medicaid contract.
- Representation of a reinsurer in an action against a retrocessionaire for liabilities arising from workers' compensation insurance and defense of a counterclaim for rescission. Obtained a judgment in favor of the reinsurer on all counts following a nine-day bench trial. The judgment was affirmed by the Third Circuit. Munich Reinsurance America, Inc. v. American National Insurance Company, No. 14-2045 (3d Cir. Feb. 3, 2015); 999 F. Supp. 2d 690 (D.N.J. 2014); 893 F. Supp. 2d 686 (D.N.J. 2012).
- Confidential arbitration on behalf of a managing general underwriter relating to the wrongful termination of a business relationship.
- Confidential arbitration on behalf of an insurer relating to coverage pursuant to a managed care agreement.
- Representation of reinsurers in confidential arbitration matters relating to claims under cut-through endorsements, variable annuity death benefits, and insolvency.
- Representation of cedents in confidential arbitration matters involving issues of coverage, notice, waiver, prejudice, the duty of utmost good faith, good-faith settlement payments and applicability of follow the fortunes.
Commercial Litigation
- Defeated a motion for a preliminary injunction seeking specific performance on supply contract for cryocoolers.
- Representation of an electronic media retailer in an action against a vendor for breach of contract. Obtained a full judgment in favor of the retailer, including attorneys’ fees, following a bench trial. The judgment was affirmed on appeal.
- Representation of an electronic media retailer in an action against a vendor over a defective product. Obtained a full judgment following a bench trial, appeal, remand and a second appeal.
- Representation of an electronic media retailer in an action against a vendor over defective merchandise. Obtained a full judgment in favor of the retailer, including attorneys’ fees, following a bench trial.
- Representation of an electronic media retailer in an action against a vendor for defective merchandise. Obtained a full judgment in favor of the retailer, including attorneys' fees, following a five-day bench trial.
- Representation of a publicly traded horticultural products company in several cases involving allegations of monopolization, attempted monopolization, breach of contract, fraud and breach of fiduciary duty. Obtained summary judgment on behalf of the horticultural products company, and affirmance by the Third Circuit.
Investigations
- Representation of two major public university systems undertaking internal investigations and audits concerning alleged non-compliance with the Jeanne Clery Disclosure of Campus Security Policy and Campus Crime Statistics Act and the anti-harassment provisions of Title IX.
- Representation of a bankruptcy court-appointed independent examiner investigating creditors' allegations of wrongdoing in the $3.6 billion leveraged buyout of the Tribune Company.
- Representation of an SEC-appointed independent examiner investigating Time Warner/AOL's historical accounting for online advertising revenues, which led to a revenue restatement of over $500 million by the company.
- New Jersey
- Pennsylvania
Firm Involvement
- Co-Chair, Insurance Practice
- Vice Chair, Litigation Department
- Member, Executive Committee
- Liaison to Supporting Women in Advancement, Growth and Results (SWAGR)
Degrees
- J.D., summa cum laude, Villanova University School of Law, 1999
- Editor-in-Chief, Villanova Law Review
- B.A., cum laude, with distinction, Boston University, 1996
Honors & Awards
- Named one of "America's Leading Lawyers in Insurance" by Chambers USA, 2025 to present
- Received JD Supra's Readers’ Choice Award for content about legal issues in the insurance industry, 2025-2026
- Named a Distinguished Leader by The Legal Intelligencer, 2023
- Named a "Local Litigation Star" in Pennsylvania by Benchmark Litigation, 2022 to present
- Named to "Who's Who Legal" list for Insurance and Reinsurance, 2016
- Named one of Pennsylvania's "Lawyers on the Fast Track" by The Legal Intelligencer, 2012
- Recipient, First Judicial District's Roll of Honor, First Judicial District's Pro Bono Committee, 2007
- Completed the Trial Academy offered by the International Association of Defense Counsel ("IADC"), 2005
- Recipient, St. Ives Medal, Villanova University School of Law, Awarded for graduating first in law school class
Clerkships
- Judge Morton I. Greenberg, U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit
- Judge James McGirr Kelly, U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania
Professional Involvement
- Member, ARIAS-US
- Co-Chair, ARIAS Law Committee
Community Connections
- Board Member, Breakthrough Bike Challenge
- Board of Advisors, Villanova Women’s Law Network